(This post may be controversial, but not just for controversy’s sake. I’d like to hear arguments pro or con about this.)
As an affiliate you can promote someone’s product and make a commission if a sale is made. It’s the merchant’s way of rewarding you for bringing in business.
In a nutshell, the way it works is you provide a special link to the product you’re promoting and when the user clicks that link to look at the product, a cookie is put on their computer. If they then buy the product (on that visit or a subsequent visit) you will get credit for that sale.
As a merchant it’s a great way to “hire” a sales force that works on commission, and as an affiliate it’s a great way to make money by promoting a product.
Nothing unethical there at all.
But did you know that simply by coming to this web site and reading this blog post, I could have “stuffed” cookies on your computer for products I’m not promoting? If you then buy that product, I’ll get an affiliate commission!
Some people don’t see the problem with that so I’ll spell it out. A commission is given in exchange for the affiliate helping to make the sale. In the case of cookie stuffing, there is no help being given by the affiliate — so the affiliate is taking money away from the merchant.
I know people who read this blog are interested in internet marketing — I could stuff the cookies of dozens of the top IM products on your computer and odds are some people are going to end up going to those sites and buying — and I’ll get a commission.
Money for nothing — what could be better?
Well, how about money that’s ethically earned? Wouldn’t that be better? I see so many people who are willing to shaft someone else in order to make a buck that it’s disgusting.
Who is getting hurt in this case? By paying a commission that wasn’t rightly earned, the merchant is losing out.
I’m not saying an “accidental sale” now and then is so horrible — but there are people out there doing underhanded things in order to make sales.
And other people who are writing software to help them do more of that. In fact, on the Warrior Forum right now there’s a piece of software for sale that allows you to do cookie stuffing. That capability is one of the major features of that software.
I asked whether that was a proper thing to do and an anonymous dork started spouting about how you can use a hammer to hit a nail or to smash someone’s head, but that doesn’t make the hammer bad.
Right.
But if the ad for the hammer talks about how you can kill someone with one blow, and how the special finish allows blood to wash right off, it’s pretty apparent the hammer’s being sold for a specific purpose.
You can make money cheating people and you can make money without cheating people.
I think cookie stuffing is cheating and people who do it are unethical.
Am I wrong?